The Baseball Jinx

Gary Carter's faith in God got him out of his sophomore slump and back into the game.

By Gary Carter, Montreal, Quebec, Canada

In this article:

As appeared in

How do you feel about jinxes? Do you think trouble comes in threes? Do you avoid black cats, walking under ladders, and the number 13 because someone told you they're unlucky?

Well, a lot of things in baseball are supposed to be unlucky too. Let me tell you about something that happened to me seven seasons ago. Ballplayers call it "the sophomore jinx."

I'd had a great rookie year in 1975—right from the opening game of the season when I crashed a home run, two singles and drove in four runs for an 8-4 win over Bob Gibson and the St. Louis Cardinals.

Alternating that season between the outfield and catching, I batted .270 with 17 home runs and 68 runs batted in, and was named the Sporting News Rookie of the Year. The newspapers said I had that magical something called "The Touch"—definitely not unlucky. The right stuff.

But during the off-season and into spring training, the press and my teammates began kidding me about this sophomore jinx that was supposed to get rookies who'd had good years. It was meant in fun, of course, and we always had a good laugh about it.

But deep in the back of my own mind, it wasn't so funny. I'd always been a big fan of the game, and I'd read of those guys. Rookies of the Year, who'd fallen apart their second season in the big leagues. It made me wonder if there really was something to this sophomore jinx.

It didn't help when, playing out of position during a spring-training game in Winter Haven, Florida, I went crashing into a brick wall in the outfield while chasing a fly ball. It took 15 stitches to close the gash in my forehead. Worse, I took a lot of ribbing from my teammates. "Stay away from Carter," they said. "If he lasts until the season..."

I made it to the season okay, but I couldn't do anything right. I was hitting way below my rookie-year average. Every time I went up to the plate, I told myself to do the same things I'd done the year before, watch the ball the same way, swing the same way, follow through the same way.

But I wasn't hitting the ball, and the harder I tried, the worse things seemed to get. The first couple months of the season, I had just a few home runs, less than 20 RBIs.

Finally, after Memorial Day, things began to turn around for me. Then, on June 6—wham! At least that's what it must have sounded like. I was playing right field that night when a fly ball was hit into short right-center field. Both Pepe Mangual, our center fielder from the Dominican Republic, and I went charging after the ball.

Pepe was yelling, "Yo tengo! Yo tengo!" and I was shouting, "I've got it! I've got it!" Just as I got my glove on the ball, we crashed into each other. The cracking sound was my thumb—broken. Diagnosis: out six weeks.

I couldn't believe it. Just when I thought I was getting things turned around, this had to happen. As a Christian, I believe that we can use bad things that happen to us for good, that God never gives us more than we can handle. I'd learned that from the Bible, and I wanted to believe it.

But now I just had to wonder what God was doing. And I knew that it must appear to my teammates that I really was jinxed.

I came back in late July, but the situation was hardly better. Into August the team played worse and worse, failing deeper into last place in the National League East. And I was getting more and more frustrated, but I had to prove that Gary Carter wasn't just some flash-in-the-pan.

Favoring the thumb that still didn't feel quite right, I strained ligaments in the same hand, then broke a bone in my other hand late in September. My season was finished. My batting average was a mere 219, with only six home runs and 38 RBIs.